“Diary of a Wimpy Kid” vs “Diary of a Delicate Conscious” by Sahmatwork


SahmatworkMy nine year old daughter, lovingly referred to as “Thinker”, brought home a book from a friend yesterday. I saw her reading it in the car, thought nothing of it, as her teacher often gives reading assignments to the class. At home I noticed that this book was occupying her time and distracting her from just about everything else. When I asked for the book she was reading, she suddenly got nervous and said, “It’s a book from my friend.”

I asked, “Did I approve this book for you?”

She said, “My teacher has the same book.”

I asked her to bring it to me, to which she made a scowling face. I said, “Now, please.”

She brought me the book, “The Diary of a Wimpy Kid”. Immediately I was suspicious. I instructed her to start homework while I looked over her new book.

I can see why this book and its series are attractive to kids. The illustrations are cartoons and the language is what they can relate to. This is what makes it so dangerous. It takes lack of morals or lack of manners and colors it up to look fun and inviting.

However, upon skimming a few pages, I quickly saw how inappropriate this book really is. She had read half the book, and I know, that she knew, it wasn’t acceptable reading. In my few minutes of seeing this boy describe magazines with women sprawled across race cars as well as mocking his own mother in this ‘diary’, I knew, enough was enough.

I informed Thinker, this book is not approved and that Dad would be talking with her later that night.

I called my husband. Knowing my emotional response wouldn’t teach her what I needed her to learn, I asked him, to somehow incorporate the message of what reading junk will do to her mind and soul. I asked him to teach her that she has a choice of what to fill her mind with.

Does this boy’s example inspire you to do your best? Does this book help you to do the right thing?

After dinner last night, Dad began his formative lesson with Thinker. And let me tell you, it was brilliance. As she was studying for her tests, he gave her a Chinese salty plum, which is like a Chinese candy, but has a strong tasting mix of sweet, salt and vinegar which demands a drink after only a few minutes. After having her suck on it for a while, he gave her another one. She asked for a drink, to which he said, “Not yet.”

I never knew how the face could contort until I saw Thinker last night, sucking on these salty plums. It was obvious she was not enjoying this experience, and for the life of me, I couldn’t figure what direction my husband was heading.

After about twenty minutes, and her thirst probably unbelievable, he brought three cups to the table.

One cup had hot clean water.

One cup had cold clean water.

One cup was full of ice.

He also brought a spoon full of coffee grounds, some sugar and some pieces of bread. He asked her, “Do you want a drink of water?”

She said, “YES! Please!”

He gave her the hot water. She took a huge gulp, slammed it down, and said,

“Yuck, it’s hot.”

He asked her, “Yes, but it helped your thirst didn’t it?”

She answered, “Yes a little.”

He added a little bit of cold water to the hot water. “Now try this.” He said.

She did and told him it was a bit better. He also added the ice and then some sugar which made her eyes widen with joy and expectation waiting for a drink. He then poured his coffee grounds into the water cup and mixed it up as well as some coffee, he had been drinking. Thinker making a confused face just watched in silence. He then tore up pieces of the bread and put it into the warm, brown mixture. He stirred it. Thinker said, “Gross, Dad.”

He said to take a sip. Thinker said, “It’s gross Dad!”

He said,

“Take a sip. Tell me how it is.”

She did, and told him how gross it tasted.

He then filled the cup of leftover ice with cold water and put it next to the brown mixture. He asked her, “Which one do you want to drink?”

Still craving liquid to quench her thirst, she asked for the nice, clean, cold cup of water. He asked her, “How do you think this drink will be?”

She smiled big and he told her she could have it.

After gulping the cold, clean water, and now recovered from her parched taste buds, he turned on the formation. He went on to explain how what we read can turn our minds and souls into that brown, cloudy mixture of muck. We have choices to make. We decide how to fill our minds and souls. He asked her, “Which one of these cups do you think you should fill up on?”

She pointed to the clean water cup, of course.

He went on pointing to the warm, brown mixture, “When you read junk or watch trash your mind turns to this.”

Thinkers eyes began to well up. *bing*  She understood.

He finished saying, “When you come to making a decision of what to read or what not to read, think of these two cups, then, make the right choice.”

Thinker was handed a saint book to read to clear her mind of all that she absorbed from the “Wimpy Kid”. I, for one, will be keeping much closer tabs on the reading choices of my children.  My ‘Work’ is never done, but I can say, with all certainty that I have a partner in the process.  A dad’s place in his daughter’s heart is immeasurable.

Copyright 2010 Sahmatwork


About Author

We welcome guest contributors who graciously volunteer their writing for our readers. Please support our guest writers by visiting their sites, purchasing their work, and leaving comments to thank them for sharing their gifts here on CatholicMom.com. To inquire about serving as a guest contributor, contact editor@CatholicMom.com.


  1. How sad that you are so insecure in your faith that you have to ban books. Whatever happened to teaching your children rather than having your child avoid things you don’t agree with? My very catholic pious brother-in-law raised (is raising) his 10 children this way (avoidance) and because of his real life banning ways his oldest 3 children had children out if wedlock, his 4th is very promiscuous and we can only pray that his next 6 will not follow suit. My son read all 4 wimpy kids books and as a reluctant reader he read every book in days time. He is a straight A third grader who’s teacher constantly tells me is the most respectful and kind child in the class. He does not treat me with any less respect because of these books, but, in fact, recognizes inappropraite behavior and how that behavior affects other people. Because of your article I am unsuscribing to this website. Hope you can keep your child under wraps for all her life. Good luck!

  2. It saddens me to see Catholicmom.com lost a subscriber because of this article, I hope to clarify any confusion it might have caused.

    I hoped to illustrate that we have not banned books in our home, however, are educating the children that they have choices to make, and will have to make for the good of themselves. As parents, we are selective, using age appropriate material in our home. As issues arise with questionable material, it makes for great discussion on what is right and wrong, and how to be able to defend themselves…in this way to be prepared to be ‘in the world’ but ‘not of it’. This was an educational exercise in teaching choices, that we all have choices, and those choices can have impact for good or not.

    Every parent will have to make judgements as to what is appropriate reading for their children and their age level. For us, this book didn’t support what we were teaching our kids, and thus we used this opportunity for a teaching moment on making choices.

    It’s certainly difficult for all parents to balance being protective and being prepared for what they will have to face in the world. They will experience so much, dating, breakups, questions of morality and all the rest, however, we hope to give right, prudent decision making skills that will prepare them for a future of success and holiness, so that they won’t have to be under wraps, but will have the armor to face the world on their own. How we armor them, well, that’s a decision for every parent to make, and we all hope and pray we have made the right choices.

    For the mother I may have offended, it sounds like you have done a great job raising your son! It really is a great responsibility to be a mother, and I applaud your results! May you and all mothers have a happy Mother’s Day!

  3. My son, who is in 4th grade, has read this series as well. (Not that I should have to defend his character, but he is also an altar server, straight A student, musician, athlete, all around well rounded kid). I read it as soon as I heard a buzz about it, and we have had many great conversations about the moral dilemmas presented in this book. (i.e. the main character makes a choice to let his friend take a fall for him, and loses his friendship for some time over it). As an adult, I’ve read many books in which the main character’s behavior is definitely not something I would model, but I have learned from the flaws of the character, even if the character is not redeemed in the end. Even though Greg (the main character) is sometimes unaware of how aloof he is to his mom’s advice, he does go to his mom for advice, which I found to be positive. The book is written in the style of a diary, in which Greg says exactly what’s on his mind. Some of that shows his immaturity and selfishness, but children of that age do struggle with these things. Although Greg makes many poor choices, I found it to be a great opportunity to open up dialogue about right and wrong. I really didn’t find this book that offensive.

  4. We just went through a similar scenario in our home with our oldest son (10 yrs). Your post helped us to deal with the situation. We did use it as a learning moment and eventually left the decision to read the book up to our son. It is so important that we give our children materials that fill their minds with virtue and foster their imaginations. It is very important to us to protect the purity of our children, and I found that this type of reading material only desensitizes children to what can become harmful to their mind and souls. Thanks for sharing.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.