The Path of a Re-vert: Coming Home to the Catholic Church

The Path of a Re-vert

The Path of a Re-vert

As  a child, my parents sacrificed that I might go to Catholic School from 1st-12th Grade.  Even if we were away on a camping trip we would drive 50 miles to go to Mass on the weekend.  They would quiz me on the readings on the drive home.  Yes, I dreaded that.

Then suddenly as a teenager in College I was free to go to Mass when I chose.  Unfortunately I chose to go less often, and then at some point stopped altogether.  After a couple years, I started to miss God.

I saw a commercial once for a free video of Jesus.  I quick wrote down the number, and had no idea who the “Latter Day Saints” were.  They  were never a topic of discussion, and I had only heard the term Mormons before in passing.  So yes, I started getting some visitors to my home.  Although I really liked all the people that I met, I listened to their message with many questions, and a critical ear.

When they came to the point where they told me I needed to get baptized, I proclaimed, ‘ No I don’t, I’ve already been baptized.”  “Your baptism was invalid, ” they told me.  Ok, we definitely have a problem Houston.  Of course by this point in time, I was already dating one of them.

I continued to date the Mormon, and pray for God to show me the truth.  I was a bit confused, and my feelings for the man I was dating wasn’t making it any easier.  However, I was still determined to follow the truth.  I prayed to God, if you show me the truth, I will surely follow.  I even fasted. (which for a 22 year old, not during lent, was extreme for me)  For weeks, he tried to convince me that Mormonism was the true way.  I know my parents were very nervous, and probably prayed ALOT during this time.

So on Christmas Eve, at Midnight, I was visiting my boyfriend, to celebrate Christmas.  For some reason, he turned the TV on to the Pope saying Mass, and promptly fell asleep right there on the floor.  Well, it was probably his biggest mistake, but aided in my salvation.  God’s plan is perfect!

Here was the Pope,  in St. Peter’s Basilica saying mass over St. Peter’s Tomb.  I cried through the whole mass.  I listened with new ears.  The mass was so perfect and complete.  Firstly we acknowledge our sin, and ask for Mercy.  Then we listen to the readings, and Gospel.  Then the Homily, where the priest can inspire based on the scriptures.  Then our offering to God and his Church.  Our petitions are presented to God, and then we are fed by Him that we may be filled with Grace.  The mass contains all the essentials to our healthy relationship with Him in a tight little package called the MASS.  We are really wrapping up so much in a mass it’s hard to believe.  There are so many elements that make our relationship with God stronger within the mass.

Well, needless to say, when my boyfriend woke up, he didn’t get a very good Christmas present.  I promptly proclaimed that I knew what the truth was,  and he was going to need to convert to Catholicism or we were all done.    I was resolute and never looked back.  Ok, looking back it seems a little harsh, but I had a very clear path in front of me, and I needed to get started.  The Catholic Church was founded 2000 years ago, and we have had successive Popes since that time.  The Saints, the miracles, the Marian appearances, Eucharistic miracles, and incorruptibles, all opened up to me.  I began to study apologetics.  I knew that if I was going to be questioned on my faith that I better know the answers.

I knew that the Church and its members had been tested all along.  I didn’t have to come up with new answers, it had been well studied, and explained.  I just needed schooling.   I wish I had learned apologetics in my Catholic High School.  We read a lot of great books in high school, but I was not prepared to answer questions about my faith on a deeper level.   I had the privilege of attending apologetics classes given by Tim Staples, Jessie Romero, and others.  I started reading books by Patrick Madrid, and Scott Hahn.  The Church became very exciting for me, like an onion, I discovered more with every layer.  I studied all the Marian visions of the past, and present.   I went on pilgrimages, prayed and fasted.   We were called RE-Verts.  We weren’t converts, because we were already Catholic.  As Reverts we had the zeal of a Convert who is just discovering the faith.   The people who were most grateful were the patients I cared for.  They were in a position of pain and/or fear, and I was acting as a pseudo chaplain as they had their biopsy or tests.   Eventually I met my husband on  He of course was grateful that I was revert, because he was a late comer to the faith, being confirmed in college.

Our story is in unique in that I had 3 Christian screening questions for my dates.  Pretty much, 98% of the population in my dating pool didn’t have the right answers.  I tried to pick a time very close to the beginning of meeting someone to get those questions out of the way so I wouldn’t wasted my time.  Before I had a chance to even ask my future husband my 3 screening questions, he emailed me the very same 3 screening questions!  Yes…he Beat me to my own test.  I couldn’t believe it.  I knew we had a good starting place of common morals, and faith, and that was the beginning of our story.

Copyright 2013 Marya Jauregui



About Author

Married to her longtime friend and mommy to 3 high energy children, who demand her constant attention, and direction, Marya serves on the board of directors for a Domestic Violence non-profit. When not working, she is working out, taking the family for nature walks and adventures, or at the movies. She lives in Southern California and feels absolutely blessed to enjoy the beauty of the area every day.


  1. Marya, pray for my husband, Paul. He is Catholic; he just doesn’t know it yet! He grew up Pentecostal, but goes to church with me. We adhere to NFP and have 9 children. Besides prayer, any suggestions for me?

    • Wonderful start! Yes, once I attended a Cursillo, and an elderly woman confided in me that she prayed for her husband to convert for 50 years! (and he DID)

      Let’s hope you are not praying so long as that. Listening to others conversion stories is always helpful. They can identify with the struggles to make that leap to Catholicism. Surprised by Truth is a book that should catch his attention. Take a look and see what you think. Please keep me posted. Involve as many in prayer for this intention as possible. Always love Novenas as well for these special intentions. Mary Undoer of Knots is a great one.

    • Thank you! Yes I returned after a brief vacation from Catholicism some 22 years ago. But the memory of that journey is still powerful. I think it helps me relate to others as they struggle to find the truth. I remember that we are especially blessed with the Fullness of the Faith.

  2. Judy Archibald on

    Hi Marya,
    Thanks for sharing your beautiful story. When you mentioned, I realized you were talking to me! My daughter is 23 and loves her faith. She hasn’t been able to find a full-time job since graduating from college, so she works part-time in retail. She is a homebody with literally no social life. She comes alive when her siblings are home, and has a wonderful zest for life. She helps me in my day care when she’s not working, and she’s going to be a great wife and mom someday. I have mentioned online dating and she is against it. I think it would be a great way to meet a like-minded young man. What can I say to convince her? Sorry this got long-winded! Thanks and God bless you.

  3. Yes. I would say this. When you are Catholic and want to marry someone who honors your faith, that’s where you need to narrow your field. With online dating at least you can prescreen. Find someone with similar interests and values and that appears attractive to you. Then you can see what a coffee meet up is like. Do you want a new friend. Or maybe it continues to something more.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.