Dealing With Miscarriage Part I: The Physical Experience

Constance Hull

Constance Hull

Editor’s note: Today, we’re pleased to welcome new contributor Constance Hull to our family. I’m particularly grateful to Constance for sharing on a very personal topic, the loss of a child in miscarriage. For more of Constance’s writing, be sure to follow her blog at Holiness in Motherhood. LMH

Dealing With Miscarriage Part I: The Physical Experience

Recently I had my final blood draw that ended of a month of bloodwork to figure out why I keep having miscarriages, post-partum depression/anxiety, and severe PMS.  It turns out that I have significant estrogen and progesterone deficiencies.  It was the miscarriages that really led to me finding, or rather she found me, a doctor who was interested in figuring out if I have a hormone issue.  I am writing about miscarriage because it is a deeply painful experience for families.  It is a pain that most people suffer in silence and there are limited resources to help those dealing with the grief.  This is further complicated by a society that has deluded itself into thinking that an unborn child is not a human baby.  This first part is just going through my own miscarriage experiences at the physical level.  I will then write posts on grief, the spiritual component and Catholic response, and also about resources that are available especially through NAPRO doctors.  So here is the beginning of my story.

Dealing With Miscarriage Part I: The Physical Experience

Dealing With Miscarriage Part I: The Physical Experience

In November of 2010, just three months after I got married to my husband, we found out that I was pregnant with our first child.  We were shocked, as most new parents are, but overjoyed.  Shortly after I found out I was pregnant I had some bleeding and called an OB/GYN I had seen advertised on the back of the parish bulletin.  He saw me the next day and told me that we had to wait another week to see if the baby was healthy or not.  After a week of fear, we were overjoyed to learn that our now daughter, Michaela, was perfectly healthy.  However, I was not prepared to learn that she had a twin who had died.  I was stunned and confused by the news.

Miscarriage was never on my radar, after all, my mother never lost any children.  What did it mean to lose Michaela’s twin?  My doctor told me that mentally it would be harder than physically, because my body would re-absorb the lost baby rather than have a full miscarriage.  My first pregnancy was a mix of joy and grief. I mourned privately.  This loss was difficult for people to understand.  They all wanted me to focus on the child who was still alive, and I was, but I also grieved the loss of her twin.   I was also violently ill with “morning sickness” for almost all 9 months.  It was a humbling experience that taught me a lot about sacrifice and marriage.

Once I had our beautiful daughter, I would wonder what it would have been like to have twins.  I would see twins and my heart would break or I would cry.  I was so thankful to God for our daughter, but it still hurt.  The grief lessoned as I began my duties as a new mom.  Sleep deprivation took over and the joy of having my daughter took hold. The grief never fully goes away, but time does dull it.

Five months after Michaela was born I discovered that I was pregnant.  We had always planned to be open to children and rarely used the Sympto-Thermal Method of NFP we had been taught.  I was in real shock at first.  I had just had a baby a few months ago along with an unplanned c-section.  After the shock wore off and the happiness started, I began to think about names.  I had always thought Michaela’s twin was a girl, but with this pregnancy I started to think about boy’s names seriously.  I had started getting the pregnancy glow and I was not nearly as sick as I was the first time around.  That should have been a clue.

I woke up one morning and just did not feel pregnant anymore.  It was a strange feeling.  I ran to the store to get a pregnancy test and the pink line was very faded.  I knew in my gut something was wrong.  Sure enough, in the middle of the night I started to bleed and by 6am I knew that our baby was gone.  It just happened to be the day that our first ultrasound was scheduled, so we went in, and after seeing the images, my doctor sympathetically told me what I already suspected.  We were scheduled to leave for DC that day, so we packed up the car and headed out of town.  We stopped at our church and asked our priest to pray with us and then proceeded onto DC.  The next few days I bled out my child and grieved.  My heart broke in new and profound ways.  I have never known the kind of grief I felt knowing that I was flushing my dead child down the toilet.  All of my miscarriages have been first trimester.

I cried off and on for months.  I was scared to get pregnant again.  My heart hurt too much.  I read the only book I could find for Catholic women on miscarriage.  The resources are scarce.  I talked it over with friends of mine who had lost babies.  I talked to our priest.  And finally, I asked our priest to do a Mass in November for families who have lost children, no matter how old.  It was a healing moment.  We never got funerals, so this was good-bye, along with prayers for the dead.  I started to feel ready to try again.  We had been open, but I had not gotten pregnant.  I don’t think I was ready.

In early January of this year, I discovered that I was pregnant for the third time.  I was so happy.  Michaela and I made a picture to take to Phil to announce that she was going to be a sister.  But this pregnancy was different.  It was awful.  I was throwing up three days a week and then spent four days feeling like I had debilitating post-partum depression.  I could barely function.  I was wondering what was different and then my early ultrasound came.  Oh how I hate those ultrasounds!  There was a sac but no baby. The doctor tried to tell me that I could just be early or ovulated late, but I knew better.  I pay attention to my body.  A week later my doctor confirmed that the baby had died very early, but my body still thought I was pregnant.  He told me my options were to see if it happened naturally or get a D & E.  For a woman like myself who works to stop abortion and help women in crisis pregnancy, the thought of the same procedure as an abortion did not sit well with me, even if it was for medical reasons and the child was dead.  I said I would try naturally.  After all, I had already been through this.

The next week was horrible.  The bleeding was slow and I felt physically drained.  Then on Sunday night, February 17, I started to bleed heavily.  At first I was relieved that it had started, but very quickly I knew that something was wrong.  When you miscarry, the blood is not supposed to flow freely out of you.  You are only supposed to fill a pad every 30 minutes to an hour at the heaviest part. I was filling pads within minutes and then seconds.  I was sent to the ER where they treated me like an actual emergency.  It is actually scarier when the ER responds to you like it is supposed to.  No waiting and a lot of running.  I just remember them trying to get two IVs in and then being rolled into surgery.  I was doped up on morphine at this point.  Having an emergency D&E is a surreal experience.  You go into the hospital bleeding to death and a couple of hours later you walk out barely bleeding.  Thankfully, I had friends who had been through this and I called them right away.  I knew it was dangerous, so I got to the hospital before I needed a blood transfusion.  Ladies, if you are bleeding this much, do not wait.  Go to the ER.  Even if they send you away, it is worth it.  I have had multiple friends who waited too long and needed transfusions and in-patient hospital stays.  You can black out and bleed to death.  It is not something to mess with.  My first miscarriage was a lot like the heaviest days of my period, not like this miscarriage that got to a point in which I would fill a pad by just standing up.

This miscarriage has been the hardest on me.  I still have not recovered physically, mentally, or spiritually from it.  I already had grief to deal with and then had to go through the trauma of a life-threatening miscarriage.  Thank God I live in this time of modern medicine! My body still has not reset to its normal cycle.

I wrote this post to give you a little background on my own personal experiences.  I hope it does not re-traumatize anyone.  I hope it makes you realize that you are not alone.  Feel free to share any of your own stories here.  Tomorrow I will write about my experiences with grief.  If you need a good saint to ask for prayers from I find St. Gianna Molla to be a good one and, of course, Our Heavenly Mother is always willing to listen and pray for you.  I always ask her to care for my babies.  God bless.

Copyright 2013 Constance Hull


About Author

We welcome guest contributors who graciously volunteer their writing for our readers. Please support our guest writers by visiting their sites, purchasing their work, and leaving comments to thank them for sharing their gifts here on To inquire about serving as a guest contributor, contact


  1. I’m so sorry to hear about your losses, Constance. The grief is so strong and often hard to express, so I am glad you are writing about this topic here.

    My own history involves two lost pregnancies The first was an unruptured ectopic, which is its own kind of awful; the second was a miscarriage, which we caught at ten weeks when the ultrasound showed no heartbeat. With the miscarriage, I had to deal with not only the grief of the loss but also the decision of whether to do a D&C or miscarry naturally. I remember avidly scouring the Internet for days, looking for information about both options. I ended up opting for a D&C, largely because I could feel myself getting more and more depressed. I needed that definite closure, and quickly. As a teacher, I also was afraid that the bleeding would hit at a bad time (during the school day when I was in the classroom). It ended up being the right decision for me. In the process, I learned that people have good reasons for having a D&C and good reasons for letting it happen naturally and it is up to each woman to make the right decision for her. It’s great that you chose to share your experiences here, painful as they are; they can help other women discern what is a very difficult and painful choice.

    Thanks again for sharing here. God bless you and your family.

    • Ginny,
      Thank you so much for sharing your story. The decision to have a D&E after finding out that your baby has died is deeply difficult, sometimes our body decides for us, like mine did, and sometimes we have to weigh the grief and emotional pain and choose the surgery. My husband and I decided that I would schedule D&E the next morning because I was so miserable, but then I hemorrhaged and had to have emergency surgery that night.The loss of a child is deeply painful and traumatic. I hope sharing my story helps others. Thank you again! God bless.


  2. Thank you for sharing your story. I too have suffered multiple miscarriages. My first pregnancy was almost perfect but the others were not. My first miscarriage was at 12wks and the other 3 were around 9wks. The last one was the hardest one to accept because we had found a cause for them (a blood clotting disorder) and thought that we were on the right path to prevent another. Unfortunately we found out too late and suffered a miscarriage a week after our first ultrasound. I spiraled into a deep depression and attempted the unthinkable. With lots of prayers and help from family and friends, I came back into the light and now have a beautiful little girl. God gives us what we need, when we need it.

    • Tori,
      Thank you for sharing your story. I am so sorry for your losses. I see a NaPro doctor who discovered that I have significant estrogen and progesterone deficiencies. I give myself 4 HCG shots in the second half of my cycle each month. My progesterone levels are great now, but my doctor just informed me that my estrogen levels did not rise this month. We will have to discuss other options. It is a difficult process. I have had periods of deep depression as well. Hormones and loss are a rough combination. I am glad that, like me, God has blessed you with amazing family and friends. He is always with us, even when we struggle to hear him. God bless.

  3. My husband and I lost our first child to miscarriage in September, just a few weeks after we had conceived. The bleeding was like an especially heavy period, but I knew the difference. Even though the bleeding was only about a week “late” if it had been a normal period, I knew that I was pregnant because of how closely I pay attention to my body. Because we lost the baby so early, my doctor was the only other person who knew about the pregnancy, but (and for this I am very grateful) when I left her a message about the miscarriage, she personally called me to check on me and talk about beginning the healing process. We have been trying to conceive again, but God has not yet blessed us with another child.
    Thank you to all of you for sharing your stories; it is so helpful to read about how other Catholic moms deal with this heart-wrenching situation. May God send you all comfort and peace.

    • Maureen,
      I am so sorry for your loss. I am glad your doctor called to check on you. Miscarriage can make us feel so alone and it helps when our doctor cares, especially given our abortion culture. I will add you to my prayers. I pray regularly for all families impacted by miscarriage. May Our Lord bless your husband and you and Our Lady wrap you in her loving mantle.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.