Managing Your Seeding Addiction: Practical Gardening Series



I love seed catalogs, they evoke such hope! I peek at them quickly as they come into the house then set them in a basket next to my reading table. When I have a block of time, which is easier to find in the winter, I pick up the stack and snuggle into my chair. With my feet up, and a cup of tea, I peruse their colorful pages and dream.

And that is when I, and most of my gardening friends, get into a world of trouble. I have learned over the years that it is easier to abstain than to moderate. Today I am going to try and help you moderate the length of your purchase order form.

It’s true that it’s less costly to grow plants from seeds than to buy them in flats. But most of us don’t have grow-tables in our homes and instead use tables next to windows with southern exposures. So consider the available space in your home for trays of seedlings…and don’t forget about pets or kids assaulting your growing efforts.

Besides the space in your home, consider the space in your garden. Can you really plant three kinds of cucumbers, four different heirloom tomatoes, and a dozen herbs? Is there enough space for five kinds of blue flowers, and are they honestly going to be as blue as the catalog pictures? You know darn well that if all the seeds germinate you’re going to have a hard time tossing the extras into the compost pile.

With so many options, consider purchasing only new varieties or old favorites. I love cucumbers and can buy one or two plants at local greenhouses. But what I can’t buy locally are the lovely round Lemon Cucumbers, so I’ll order the seeds. Marigolds grow well and many of my favorites are also found at nearby growers, except the airy 30” ‘Cottage Red’. So I’d order these seeds too.

Consider growing a new plant that was just introduced into the market and offers a twist, such as the small cherry tomato ‘Sunchocola’. This new introduction from Burpee Seeds is a dark burgundy-red,  has a rich heady flavor and would be wonderful alone or on a salad of peppery greens.

Another thing to consider is the level of difficulty germinating seeds. I have the darndest time holding onto seeds to scarify them with sand paper or (yikes!) a knife. And using a heating pad under a flat of ‘Bells of Ireland’ to keep them warm is not the most brilliant of ideas no matter how many layers of protective plastic used. Check instructions for propagation method. If it’s only one sentence long, and contains the words ‘easily germinated’, go for it.

And speaking of instructions, double check references for growing conditions. Many catalog suppliers really stretch the truth not only about what Zone a plant will grow in, but also the size of the flower or its invasive tendencies. Get suspicious when plants have extremely close-up pictures of flowers, descriptive words like vigorous grower or naturalizing, or suggest they grow well in a protected site.

Take a little time to discern how you’ll spend your gardening dollar, and you may be able to use your dining room for meals this spring.

Copyright 2014, Margaret Rose Realy. Obl. OSB


About Author

Margaret Rose Realy, Obl. OSB lives an eremitic life and is the author of Cultivating God’s Garden through Lent, A Garden of Visible Prayer: Creating a Personal Sacred Space One Step at a Time, 2nd Edition, and A Catholic Gardener’s Spiritual Almanac. A freelance writer with a Benedictine spirituality, Margaret has a master’s degree in communications and is a Certified Greenhouse Grower, Advanced Master Gardener, liturgical garden consultant, and workshop/retreat leader.


  1. Great thoughts. I have a seed catalog addiction of my own. My husband just rolls his eyes but he certainly likes the results (thinks they’re quite tasty!). Nice article.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.