A Rich Tapestry of Faith: How St. Kateri Rescued My Family's Catholic Identity

Photo copyright 2015 Tiffany Walsh. All rights reserved.

Photo copyright 2015 Tiffany Walsh. All rights reserved.

I absolutely love reading conversion stories. Each is unique and inspiring, and as a cradle Catholic who lacks such a dramatic story of her own, I seek them out at every opportunity. I own a large collection of memoirs written by converts, and I reread them often.

In a sense, however, even cradle Catholics have to make their faith their own as adults in order for it to “stick.” I, like everybody, have my own story of faith, and foundational to that is the story of my family. It is because of my parents’ example that I remain Catholic, but that came about as the result of a somewhat circuitous journey…

My mom is Italian, and her immediate and extended family were, during her childhood, all Catholic. My native Western New York is, in fact, full of the descendants of Italian and Polish immigrants, and we have many beautiful, historic churches to show for it.

My dad is of German and indigenous descent, specifically Mohawk. Growing up, he was raised nominally Protestant. My dad and his siblings were baptized in a Lutheran church, but the family never attended with any regularity. Through the years, he recalls belonging to a slew of different churches, noting with amusement that his membership usually had to do with their baseball team.

The result of all of this is that when I was a little girl, my dad did not regularly attend Mass with us. My mom had retained her childhood Catholic faith, and she and my dad were married in the Church, but the raising of my sisters and I in the faith fell to her. It is interesting to me that my older sister recalls us attending Mass fairly frequently when we were growing up, but I do not. I remember attending on Christmas and Easter, which is also when my dad would come with us. But what I DO remember are the religious education classes.

Cradle Catholics out there who attended public school, and thus needed to attend weekly religious education in order to receive your sacraments, let us all band together, yes?! I am hoping that some of you had a positive experience in religious education, but I unfortunately did not, mostly because I put zero effort into it. My recollection? Absolutely excruciating. I remember sitting in those classes, watching the clock, my mind wandering every which way, and just waiting for them to be over. I did not see the relevance of these classes to anything else in my life. I had a strong belief in God, but what the catechists were trying to teach us each week seemed far removed from the way I thought about God.

I never doubted that God was there, I just wished that I did not have to sit through those classes each week. It did not help that we lacked observance of any Catholic traditions in our home, and I did not really understand how being Catholic was different from being any other kind of Christian. Definition of Protestantism vs. Catholicism? I had no clue. The Catholic faith did not seem profound, meaningful, or distinctive in any way to me. I figured all belief in God was similar, and that it did not matter.

This continued until I received the Sacrament of Confirmation in early high school. Then something changed. One of my aunts joined a prayer group and invited us to come. This touched a need within my mom’s heart, and she, my sisters, and I started attending. From that point forward, the fellowship, prayer, and spiritual support moved my mom to more fully embrace her Catholic faith. We started going to Mass every Sunday and praying the rosary. Even I enjoyed the prayer group. The ladies were fun! And a few of my cousins were there, too.

By this point, much of my mom’s family had left the Church. They all remain devoted Christians, but none remained Catholic. The temptation for us to fall away was right there, very strong, and I am ever so grateful that we remained.

With our renewed Mass and prayer group attendance, my dad started to see how important this had become to us. One day, something extremely fortuitous happened: while reading the newspaper, he saw an article about a brand-new local parish, one that is completely unique in our state in that it is housed on Native American land. This sparked his interest due to his own Mohawk heritage. He showed the article to my mom, and they agreed to go to Mass there.

This church is absolutely adorable and quaint. Very cozy, and decorated in indigenous art, it is a beacon of the faith amongst people who may not have otherwise considered a Catholic church. Based on my impression and experience, this is a very sensitive issue amongst indigenous people, and understandably so. The past is rife with heavy-handed (and worse) tactics to mold Native Americans into what the larger society would rather have them do, and as you can imagine, this type of persuasion is not very effective. Generally speaking, Native people have a strong belief in God, but Christianity is not usually their chosen path.

Thus, this parish is especially meaningful in an area with a relatively large Native American population. My dad is a very quiet and reserved man. He did not say much at the time, but he wanted to keep attending Mass there, and this spoke volumes. So we did.

A year or two later, my dad confided that he would like to receive instruction toward becoming Catholic. After nearly twenty-five years of marriage, my dad entered the Church at the Easter Vigil, and he and my mom were finally united in faith.

I remember the Mass when he was received into the Church quite well, and we were all under the impression that his chosen patron saint was St. Andrew, as that was his own grandfather’s name. When he went forward to receive the Sacrament of Confirmation, and Father asked him to name his saint, he said:

“Kateri Tekakwitha.”

It was one of those moments that is so unexpected, but yet makes perfect sense. The Lily of the Mohawks. There really was no one else in the Communion of Saints who meant more to my dad than she who represented his people. I think she was behind the scenes all along, interceding for us all, and paving the way for us to share faith in Christ and His Church.

My dad’s conversion had a profound effect on me. After that, we all attended Mass together and prayed for each other. Being Catholic as a family was suddenly very meaningful to all of us.

When I entered college, and later graduate school, this teenaged time in my family faith life was instrumental in my not abandoning the Church. It was not, however, a completely smooth path to my very happy faith life as an adult. How did that all go down, you ask? What saints were involved in that particular adventure, along with St. Kateri? Stay tuned; part two will be coming your way in a future post…

Until then, are you a cradle Catholic or a convert? In either case, why are you a Catholic today? If you had to name one reason, what would it be? I would love to hear your experiences!

Photo courtesy of Cristina Trinidad. All rights reserved.

Photo courtesy of Cristina Trinidad. All rights reserved.

Copyright 2015 Tiffany Walsh
Photos courtesy of Tiffany Walsh and Cristina Trinidad. All rights reserved.



About Author

Tiffany Walsh is a wife and mother, a native western New Yorker, and a college librarian. She is a cradle Catholic who rekindled her childhood faith as a graduate student via her love of books, and is the author of Exploring the Catholic Classics, part of the Stay Connected Journals for Catholic Women series. She enjoys writing about faith, crafting, dance, fitness and wellness. Visit her blog at Life of a Catholic Librarian.


  1. What a beautiful accounting! I’ve enjoyed reading over at your blog and listening to your podcasts. Its grrat to see you here!

    We just visited her shrine in Auriesville along with the North American Martyrs shrine. Her shrine is lovely and just makes one feel connected to Christ.

    • Hi Ashley! Thank you so much for commenting! Oh my goodness, I’ve been to Auriesville too! Around this time, when I was a teenager, so it’s been awhile. 😉 But I loved it, and I have told my kids and husband that I want to take them there, because it’s not that far from us. Maybe a 5ish hour drive? A very peaceful place, and so rich in the faith, to be sure.

  2. I am a convert. I did not take my journey to Confirmation seriously until Jesus taught me what it meant and what my personal relationship was and should be with the Eucharist. Since my confirmation, the Holy Spirit has truly kindled the flame and pushed me into ministry, and I am grateful to be Catholic. I, too, love conversion stories!

    • Hi Hillary! Thank you so much for leaving your story! It is fascinating to me to read converts stories, in particular, because I am a cradle Catholic. And the Eucharist? As a kid, I had no idea, but as an adult, it is now central to my faith. How could I ever leave the Eucharist? Seals the deal. 🙂 My favorite verse from the Gospels is from John, just following the Eucharistic discourse: “To whom else shall I go, Lord? You have the words of eternal life.” Thank you so much for commenting, Hillary!

  3. Hi Tiffany – Thank you so much for sharing your story. It brought tears to my eyes! I am a cradle Catholic who fell away for a number of years until God gave me a pretty big and sad experience to bring me home. I’m so grateful for that. My nominally Lutheran husband came into the faith about 10 years after I came back. I’m so thankful that my whole family practices our faith together.

    • Hi Sara! How beautiful, thank you for this comment! Indeed, I have experienced God speaking to me via a low point in my life, and this certainly gets our attention, yes? I’ll go into this more in my reversion story, part two. 🙂

  4. Beautiful! I really enjoyed reading this. We have a school named after St. Kateri here in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. (I still refer to it as Blessed Kateri!). So fascinating to read about your experience in the Church and about your heritage. I dropped the ball on getting my 15-year-old son confirmed but hopefully we can still work that out somehow…

    Looking forward to reading Part 2!

    • Thank you, Jo! And what a beautiful area of the world you are from! Let’s ask for St. Kateri’s intercession, we’ll get your son confirmed. 😉 I’m deciding now whether I’ll post part 2 next month, or wait until the fall. So many things I want to write about!

  5. I also love conversion stories and this story was beautiful. I am also a cradle catholic. I remember liking and hating the religious education classes on and off throughout the years but I remember liking them more than hating them. My father passed away when I was very young and all through my life my mom and others would talk about my dads strong faith and traditions he would do at holidays and how he loved visiting churches when he visited new cities. I think hearing those stories over the years really intrigued me and made me want to learn more about the faith and stay faithful. I also had fun youth group experiences in high school and college that encouraged me to keep learning.

    • Beth Anne! So happy to see you over here! And WOW, what a powerful story. I didn’t realize that your dad had passed away, I’m so sorry to hear this. It sounds to me like your dad has been interceding for you for quite some time! And his great example, even with you being so young, obviously had a lasting impression. This is what all parents long for. 🙂 What a beautiful witness!

  6. Tiffany – I loved your post!! I am a cradle Catholic – my religious ed experiences, pretty similar . I too felt I shouldered part of the blame for getting nothing from them due to my own participation. I remember a lot of collage making and textbook reading -though I am grateful to each man and woman who took their time to attempt to share the faith. I am sure there were seeds there that in due time I allowed through God’s grace to sprout.

    I also think you were SPOT ON reminding that even those without a dramatic conversion story probably have a pretty significant ‘reversion’ or “my choose to day – version” story to share!! My family barely practiced Catholicism when I was a kid, a limped lukewarmly through young adulthood, but through an invitation to a bible study and discovering the scriptures my heart was set ablaze in my early 30s – and praise the Lord stays fanned today!!

    • Hi Allison! Thank you so much for commenting! What an inspiring story. It sounds like our experiences were indeed quite similar. I am intrigued by your observation that despite our (at the time) apathy and lack of effort, those religious education classes likely instilled seeds that bore fruit many years later. I think that you are right! That’s a beautiful way of looking at it.

      I love personal stories, especially of the religious variety. Everybody has a story, even us cradle Catholics! Love it!

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.