Unequally Yoked Marriage: 6 Ways to Make it Work


It’s not a secret that I am unequally yoked. I’ve been asked, how I make my marriage work. My husband, an atheist, joins us for weekly Mass; we send our children to Catholic school; he volunteers there too. We also say grace before meals and when I cantor, he sits with the boys in the pew, making sure they participate according to their age levels. For a while, it was difficult for me to explain how I made it work, because it was so ingrained in the fabric of my marriage and conversion back in May of 2012. Here are 6 ways, by no means exhaustive, of how I make my marriage work as a Catholic, married to an atheist.

Unequally Yoked Marriage 6 Ways to Make it Work

Copyright 2016 Cristina Trinidad. All rights reserved.

  1. Pray: You’ll need to pray in every season. Pray for him, for whatever he needs, for God’s will to be done, for his days to be fruitful, to be open to the tapping on the door to his heart. My preferred way of praying for my husband is while he’s sleeping. I just place my arm over his chest and hold him as I pray my intentions for him. I ask to see him as God sees him and to respond to him that way too. I ask that his heart softens towards me and my journey just as my heart softens to his. Pray for yourself – why not? I pray for myself all the time.
  2. Never give up: Just when you think there’s nothing left to be done, you’ll be surprised. He may just want to go to that Mass with you, or special church event. This may not mean that he’s converting per se, but he’s converting how he thinks about your spiritual life. This is a partnership, a relationship, a give and take and give again. He also may just surprise you and take a picture of a cathedral for you while he’s away on business because he knew you would love to see it. (Yep, that just happened to me a couple of weeks ago.)
  3. Remember him and Him: If you’re a new convert, this is for you. When you are new in your conversion journey, it’s a love affair. Truly. You can’t stop thinking about it and everything you think, do or say is seen through the lens of faith. You want to spend all of your time in this new faith, this new love. This is how you loved your significant other when you first met, remember? The world stopped and started with them. That’s got to be a hard thing for your husband to live through (in my case). I’m not saying dampen your journey or keep it all to yourself (I tried that – HARD), but don’t forget him in the process. It’s a tough balancing act, I know. Pray for the grace to be balanced in this area. The more mindful of it you are the more it will show that your love for him hasn’t changed, just expanded to include God.
  4. Practice the Little Way: Love your significant other in little ways. I highly recommend reading St. Therese of Lisieux A Story of a Soul. She created this way of loving God and it works just the same as loving your husband, your fellow Christian, even people you don’t like. “St. Therese translated ‘the little way’ in terms of a commitment to the tasks and to the people we meet in our everyday lives.” This goes hand in hand with number 3, I think. You can live the ‘Little Way’ for God and for your husband knowing in your heart, that it’s all grace. My priest said something to me once that really put things into perspective for me. He said “Cristina, of course this is hard. Think of this as school, you’re in the 5th grade of your faith and he hasn’t even gotten through Kindergarten, yet. You’re trying to make him understand algebra. Just help him count.” Exactly. WHOA! Put more succinctly, meet him where he’s at!
  5. Trust: Just because a conversion has taken place doesn’t mean you throw the baby out with the bath water. You fell in love for reasons beyond your faith. From that common ground, trust that it will work out the way it’s supposed to – if there is love. I know it sounds very cliche, and maybe it’s supposed to. I really believe that if there is love, especially where there is a belief that marriage is a sacrament – something not to be broken, a sign that you are set apart for God and something truly holy; it will work. He’s and your husband is on your side. That’s a great recipe for success.

If you’re looking for another resource, and if you’ve read my blog long enough, you know that another resource is always necessary – take a read of The Secret Diary of Elizabeth Lesseur: The Woman Whose Goodness Changed Her Husband from Atheist to Priest. Almost too good to be true, Amazon’s summary goes on to state:

This inspiring book gives you a splendid example of how to live as a Christian in a secular environment that can be indifferent or hostile to your Faith. For Elisabeth Leseur had two great loves: God and her husband Felix, who was an atheist. Felix loved Elisabeth as well; yet to their mutual sorrow, he couldn’t share the life of the Spirit that Elisabeth cherished.

Occasionally the happiness of their life together in upper-class Parisian society was shattered by Felix’s frustration and impatience. How could such an intelligent woman waste her time, as he saw it, with ignorant superstitions? Sometimes he and his friends would even ridicule and mock her faith.

But Elisabeth loved Felix too much to allow their home to degenerate into an emotional war zone. She realized that confrontations and arguments were useless; she chose instead to keep quiet and pray for Felix. In her secret diary she recorded how she used his efforts to destroy her faith as means to grow in love for him and for God.

If you do happen to read this book by Elizabeth Lesseur, or have read it, do tell me what you think of it. Have I missed anything on this list? If you’re in an unequally yoked marriage and there is a tip I’ve not included, please for the love of dark chocolate brownies, add it in the comments!

Copyright 2016 Cristina Trinidad


About Author

We welcome guest contributors who graciously volunteer their writing for our readers. Please support our guest writers by visiting their sites, purchasing their work, and leaving comments to thank them for sharing their gifts here on CatholicMom.com. To inquire about serving as a guest contributor, contact editor@CatholicMom.com.


  1. Wow, Cristina, this is beautiful! Thank you for openly sharing about your marriage. I have always wondered how couples with completely different faiths (or one having no faith) make it work, and this has been really eye-opening. Thank you!
    I really, really need to read Elizabeth Lesseur’s diary. It’s been on my “must read” list for literally the past couple years, and it sounds amazing!

    • Thank you SO much, Annemarie! The Diary of Elizabeth Lesseur is a must. You feel as if you have a friend with you walking on the marriage path. I think it’s helpful even if you don’t have an unequally yoked marriage Thank you for stopping by! 😀

  2. I needed so much to read this right now. SO MUCH. I’m a new convert married to an atheist and to say it’s been stressful is an understatement. Beautiful, amazing, exhilarating, yes…but also exhausting, stressful, and sometimes heartbreaking too.
    I have been praying so hard for the Lord to show me how to do this, how to love them both and love them both well, because I don’t know how that works or what that even looks like.
    Just seeing these words on the page helps. Knowing I’m not the first or only one to take this journey helps.
    Thank you for writing this.

    • Oh Kristie!!!! I am SO glad you landed on this post today. I will be praying for you and your husband. Not so much for conversion, but for understanding, empathy and care with one another. God, will take care of the conversion 😉 <3

  3. C, I’m not at all surprised that your first piece at Catholic Mom is already touching hearts. You have the gift in your writing! I’m in a mixed marriage situation, as you know, and as the saying goes, “it ain’t easy!” 🙂 I have learned through the years that the only person I can focus on changing is ME. It’s not up to me to decide that my husband needs to change. I certainly have enough to work on just within myself! My Guardian Angel must be *exhausted*. :0 God will do the rest, in His own time.

    • I just said that to someone…choosing to work on myself than trying to change someone else. In light of the podcast we just recorded, aren’t we adults 😉 love ya, girl <3 and always praying for you.

  4. Welcome to Catholicmom.com!! It’s an awesome community :). Fabulous post…. And I LOVE the Secret Diary of Elizabeth Lesseur! My husband bought it for me for Mother’s Day a few years ago…. I should get it out again.

    • Thank you for the warm welcome, Michelle! I’ve been a reader for years, and close friends with other contributors. Only a matter of time, as they say. 🙂

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.