Is Extreme Couponing Moral?

3

My sons and I have recently been watching “Extreme Couponing” on TLC. For those of you unfamiliar with the program, it showcases people who have turned using coupons into a career. They save their families thousands of dollars each year via the use of coupons. Most of the episodes we have watched feature grocery totals of hundreds of dollars costing under fifty dollars (some were under ten)! The extreme couponers featured have stuffed their houses full of the items they have purchased in large numbers because there was a good deal.

I know money is tight right now. The economy has been struggling for quite a while and some of the families featured were in truly dire situations. They have made couponing into a full-time job and saved the equivalent of a good salary while being able to feed their families. I can only admire their resourcefulness.

But, what about the person who can afford the groceries but chooses to take up extreme couponing anyway? Is there a point when saving money becomes less about good sense and more about being unethical?

What is involved in extreme couponing? One must take advantage of multiple good deals. One must not only purchase only what is on sale but also must have a coupon for it. Double coupons and combining manufacturers coupons with store coupons are also used. Some extreme couponers actually make money on the products they buy!

Extreme couponers do nothing illegal. They do their research and make the best use of the offers and policies that are in place. They get around limits on the number of coupons or items purchased by making multiple transactions. My moral quandary comes in with the scale of the purchases and the fact that they are leaving one store with close to a thousand dollars worth of goods that they have paid less than ten percent of the purchase price for.

I have worked in retail. I know that there is a considerable mark-up on the goods sold. Yet, that mark-up is what pays for the workers’ salaries and the utilities and general upkeep of the store – all money that goes back into the economy and helps provide jobs for people. Obviously, one extreme couponer will not break a store’s bottom line, but one must realize that someone does need to pay for the goods that person is taking out of the store.

Yes, the store will be reimbursed for manufacturer coupons, but double coupons and store coupons are offers the store makes in order to get more people into the store so that they will spend money on other products while they are there. In the case of extreme couponing, the store is the one taking the hit, and by extension, the people who work for it.  Stores may also need to change their coupon policies as a result, thereby hurting all those who used them the way they were intended.

I also question the appropriateness of the stockpiles of goods some of these extreme couponers amass. While some do donate their excess to charitable organizations, that seems to be the exception rather than the rule. Many of the products will expire before they ever have the chance to be used. One couponer bought 100 bottles of medicine because she was making money on each bottle. Is it morally appropriate to hoard products in this fashion?

I do not know the answer to these questions, but I think they are important to think about, especially if extreme couponing becomes more and more popular.

Copyright 2011 Patrice Fagnant-MacArthur

 

Share.

About Author

We welcome guest contributors who graciously volunteer their writing for our readers. Please support our guest writers by visiting their sites, purchasing their work, and leaving comments to thank them for sharing their gifts here on CatholicMom.com. To inquire about serving as a guest contributor, contact [email protected]

3 Comments

  1. Patrice, I will admit that I’d never seen or heard of this television show before you posted this article. I went over and watched a few of the clips on the website and would really like to tune in for a full show. From what I saw there, some of the folks highlighted seemed to be bordering on an obsession. But some of the folks were using their knowledge of coupons to support charities. It does seem to be a “gaming” of the system and something that could be economically disastrous for companies and retailers if the trend becomes widespread. Thanks for bringing up such an interesting topic!

  2. Not only are they hoarding, but they clear the shelves, so that any customer coming into the store AFTER them, hoping to use the coupon and get a deal, can’t even get the product! That’s immoral.

  3. tarynn snodgrass on

    I agree with the above comments. I am a couponer, I have even taught classes on couponing. But I am not an extreme couponer. Those couponers, who, like me, do it responsibly, only stock up on products for a month’s use at best. I stock up on products when they are free or very low priced, so that I dont pay retail on it next week. The people on this show are hoarders. There is no good reason to have 20+ bottles of detergent. 3-4 will get you to the next sale. I also only coupin at walmart. They dont do their own coupons, so the only money they lose out on is their price matching policy, which I have been using for years anyway. The people like those on the show are going to harm couponing for all those who do it responsibly.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.