"Good Enough is Good Enough" Book Club: Chapters 3 and 4

3

Welcome to the Good Enough is Good Enough Book Club! We’re reading Good Enough is Good Enough by Colleen Duggan.

"Good enough is good enough" book club ch 3 and 4 by Deanna Bartalini (CatholicMom.com)

Created in Canva for CatholicMom.com.

I must first say that I love this book and wish I’d had it when I was raising my children. But even as a mom of adults I found plenty of things to think about while reading.

Today we’re looking at Confessions 3 and 4. First up, “I Don’t Know How to Keep My Kids Catholic,” which I think most of us think at one or many more than one point while we are raising our kids. When my kids were young we had a home-based religious education program which used the Sunday readings as the starting point. My husband usually led the first part of the lesson which was reading and discussing the upcoming Mass readings. The reading and listening parts went fine, but when it came time to discussion questions, which were in the book, it became, well, predictable. No matter the readings, our son would offer, in quick succession, the following names, “Moses, John the Baptist, Jesus, God” as the answer. We all soon tired of this so we stopped asking the “who” questions. It just wasn’t worth it.

The biggest takeaway from this chapter for me:

I felt so overwhelmed and frustrated with parenting because I thought I was responsible for the miracle, I thought my efforts alone would ensure the raising of good, Catholic children. I thought it was my job to produce educated citizens capable of serving their neighbor. But it’s not my job to do those things; it’s Jesus’ job.

We need to let go, people. We cannot force our children to be anything. If God saw fit to give us free will, who are we to think we can somehow take free will from our children where faith is concerned? As Colleen says, “It is our job to show up with the necessary supplies and to be faithful.” That’s our responsibility, to be faithful.

Now, to be honest, sometimes things don’t turn out the way we hope and expect with our children, especially in regard to faith. It happens in many families. It’s that way in my family; right now, only one of our children is fully practicing Catholicism while the other wanders in and out. My husband and I pray, asking often for Mary, Undoer of Knots, to intercede. We are faithful and have been good, not perfect, examples to our children. That is what God asks of us and we need to remember that as we raise our children in the faith.

Confession 4 “ I Don’t Like Watching my Children Suffer” was not easy to read for many reasons. First, as Colleen describes her problems with breastfeeding her son, I watched my daughter go through the same thing two months ago with her son. Different outcome, but I had to keep reading to know that. Second, though the book is open and honest throughout, this chapter hit me especially hard. In some ways, it helped me remember not to dismiss the blessings or trials in our life. It also reminded me to not give up hope and to stay focused on the goal and the plan as to how to get to the goal.

We can’t control what happens to our children. As we do out best to provide and care for them, life moves forward and often it moves in ways we’d rather not have happen or would never have imagined. This can be in both negative and positive ways. All of us want the best for our children, but as Colleen says, “I don’t need to create a game plan for success for my kids because God already has that covered.”

I think part of the paths life takes us that we’d rather not go down involves making peace with the situation, learning from it, and moving forward. I’ve never experienced serious health problems with my children, but I did with my husband. It has been a big adjustment and sometimes I’m reminded of what is gone because of the problems. But then I remember what I still have, my husband, and see how God is using him and how we are growing together. God gives us what we need to overcome difficult situations, be they health, finances, addictions, or whatever else life throws at us; we can hold onto that promise. Suffering is not fun or easy and the world tells us it is pointless. We know that’s not true; suffering helps to purify us and grow. So, while we don’t want to watch our children suffer, sometimes they have to. Of course, when the suffering is from sickness, disease or disability, we do all we can to help. But in doing all we can, remember that we can’t do it all and must call on God to guide us.

To Ponder, Reflect, and Discuss:

  1. When you think about raising your children in the faith; do you spend more time worrying about it or passing on the truth, beauty, and goodness of Catholicism? What, if anything, needs to change in the way you transmit the faith?
  2. How have you been surprised or disappointed with your plans for your children?
  3. Do you see the difference between suffering that comes with life and is out of our control and the suffering created by choices and decisions made? How can we help our children learn that difference and learn that suffering cannot always be avoided?

Feel free to comment on your own thoughts from this week’s reading, your impressions and reflections, and/or your answers to these questions.

"Good enough is good enough" book club ch 3 and 4 by Deanna Bartalini (CatholicMom.com)

Created in Canva for CatholicMom.com.

Next week, we’ll cover Chapter 5 and the Conclusion. For the complete reading schedule and information about our Book Club, visit the Book Club page.


Copyright 2018 Deanna Bartalini

Share.

About Author

Deanna G. Bartalini, is a Catholic writer, speaker, and educator. She and her husband Deacon John have two married children and a grandson. Deanna loves teaching about Catholicism and how it fits into our daily lives. She writes at DeannaBartalini.com, serves as the editor of the NewEvangelizers.com blog, and is a contributor there as well as at AmazingCatechists.com. Deanna contributed to A Catholic Mom's Prayer Companion published by Ave Maris Press. She has written “Invite the Holy Spirit into Your Life: Growing in Love, Joy, Peace, Patience, Kindness, Goodness, Faithfulness, Gentleness and Self-Control” one book in the series of the Stay Connected Journals for Catholic Women published by Gracewatch Media. Deanna is available to lead retreats and speak at catechist and ministry events.

3 Comments

  1. Chapter 4 was difficult for me to read too. It was gripping and heart-wrenching and I must confess to having shed a few tears. I have had children with health problems and it is so very difficult. I remember thinking that, particularly right after a diagnosis, that it’s like walking around with a knife in your heart. But the Lord has given mothers (and all women) an ever expanding capacity to love. Ironically, the more we suffer such hardships the better we are able to love, and the better our vision for seeing what really matters. Colleen Duggan clearly experienced that. God is faithful. This is a good book!

    • Thanks be to God he has given us such a way to love! Watching those we love suffer is very hard, especially when it is our children.

Leave A Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.