

Thinking Like A Saint: Discernment of Spirits in the Catholic Tradition
By

Thinking Like A Saint: Discernment of Spirits in the Catholic Tradition
By Father Timothy Gallagher, O.M.V.
Published by Ignatius Press
Recently, Ignatius’ rules for discernment have kept popping up everywhere for me, and I felt like it was time to learn more about them. Although I have read the fourteen rules for discernment before, and was familiar with some of Father Timothy Gallagher’s writings, I was drawn to go deeper by reading his new work, Thinking Like a Saint: Discernment of Spirits in the Catholic Tradition (Ignatius Press).

In the preface, Father Gallagher outlines a vision for helping us to think like the saints did, not just in holy moments of prayer, but in the messy moments of life. Father Gallagher has been teaching and writing on the discernment of spirits for forty years, so he has a lot of expertise on guiding souls through challenging decision-making. The difference in this book is that he is situating Ignatius’ fourteen rules within the broader teaching of the Church through quotes from other saints and holy people.
It took me a few chapters to get into the flow of the book, but after Father Gallagher lays out Saint Ignatius’ fourteen rules for discernment and gives an overview on the lens to see them through, the fourteen following chapters delve deeper into each one of the rules. After presenting the rule, Father Gallagher spends a few pages sharing his thoughts on the rule and how to apply it to our lives, and then the last part of the chapter is a collection of saints’ quotes or writings that are “witnesses” to the rule. You find that these witnesses are saying the same thing as Ignatius but in their own words and with their unique perspective. Father Gallagher frequently comments in italics after various quotes, continuing to engage readers until the end.
What Are the Rules of Discernment About, Anyway?
Saint Ignatius’ fourteen rules discernment all revolve around paying attention to our thoughts and what is from the “good spirit” or the “enemy.” The goal is to draw closer to God, so the rules take a deep dive into the principles of desolation (feeling far from God) and consolation (feeling the sweetness of being close to God). For example, when in a state of desolation, make no change to the prayer practices you committed to in a state of consolation.
One becomes aware very quickly of how universal the experiences of consolation and desolation are in prayer. If we are experiencing desolation, we must examine if there are things we need to repent of, or if we just need to be persistent and consistent in prayer and wait for the Lord to console us again. Father Gallagher tells us that if we give in to spiritual desolation, we will draw farther and farther away from God. He identifies four qualities of spiritual desolation: shame, isolation, self-doubt, and a sense of irreparable disaster. He tells us there is no shame in experiencing it, for when we unmask the lies and reject them, we grow closer to God.
If we take the counsel of Saint Ignatius and Father Timothy Gallagher, we are surely going to grow in an awareness of the spiritual battles around us, and draw strength from the Lord to reject the lies and suggestions of the enemy.
Immediately Fruitful
I love Father Gallagher’s calm, simple style of writing that is precise yet clarifying. He gives many examples of what these decisions would look like in practice, which makes it very practical. And he offers insights into how other saints describe these spiritual experiences.
Over the course of the weeks I spent reading this book, I became more aware of my own thoughts and the movements towards God or away from Him, so these teachings had instant effect. Because the inspirations of God or the devil can be subtle, we have to really pay attention to what’s going on inside of us. This book was immediately fruitful in that I started paying closer attention to my interior movements daily.
If you or someone you know wants to learn about Saint Ignatius’ rules for discerning thoughts, this book is a great summary of the teachings and how other saints have lived the rules out as well. I think this book is perfect for the man or woman of today who wants to take their spiritual life seriously, because you can’t grow without being attuned to the inspirations you are listening to, or aware of the movements leading you closer to or further away from God.

Ask for Thinking Like a Saint from your favorite Catholic bookseller, or order online from Amazon.com or the publisher, Ignatius Press.
Copyright 2026 Allison Auth
Image (top): detail from cover






Leave a Reply