

Guilt vs. Repentance: Truly Forgiving Ourselves
By

The Catholic Church provides us many seasons and feasts to focus on various areas of our life. Our spiritual growth though, is based on our response to those occasional summons when we have been participating in the Holy Mass, reading spiritual books, attending retreats or touched by a hymn we have heard so often. For some, these remain as (mere) transitory experiences, for others, profound life-changing experiences.
Moments like these give us new perspective and direction. They can invoke guilt or repentance. Guilt tends to paralyse. Excessive guilt creates resentment and depression. In its contrast, repentance catalyses. It is therefore essential for us to realise how we respond in our daily walk with the Lord and especially in those special moments of grace and insight.
For godly sorrow produces a salutary repentance without regret, but worldly sorrow produces death. (2 Corinthians 7:10)

Guilty?
According to a study by Allen Bergin at the Brigham Young University, people are likely to respond to guilt by simply waiting until feelings of guilt subsided; attempting to convince themselves it was really not that bad; doing something righteous to balance their account; promising themselves (and God) that they would avoid it the next time; punishing themselves by calling themselves worthless; trying not to think about it; and avoiding spiritual contexts because they felt unclean.
Operating on guilt is debilitating and destructive. It costs. The emotion, in itself, has the strength to eat us up from inside. Holding it in builds a storm. Repentance, on the other hand, is liberating. The investment in repentance is rejuvenating, constructive, and long lasting.
There are times I have said or done things intentionally that hurt someone deeply. Each time I have the choice to ask for forgiveness and then to either accept that forgiveness or beat myself up about it every time I think of it even if my friend has long forgotten the incident. I can continue to make reparations for months to come and continue to feel lesser in the relationship. Worse off if the other person recognises this weakness and uses it to their advantage.
Patterns like this can emerge in any interaction or communication, be it with parents, couples, siblings, friends, colleagues, or subordinates. It could also emerge therefore in the way we relate to God our Father. Even after Confession and penance at the confessional, we may continue to remain in guilt. God forgives us and even forgets. The person involved would also have most likely forgiven and forgotten, but are we able to forgive ourselves?
True Repentance
Confession is a significant step towards our newfound yearning. A sincere confession requires sincere self-analysis: an awareness and strength to face the unpleasant facts about ourselves and understand the effect of our action on those involved. Allan E. Bergin says:
It is ironic that we fear disclosing to Him who already knows what we have done. We perhaps punish ourselves more by withholding than the Lord would ever do. (Psychology and Repentance, October 4, 1994)
As in psychotherapy, this process involves overcoming defences to bring about true self-revelation. Confession therefore is painful, but true repentance does not end here. It comes to completion when this awareness leads to reconciliation, restoration, the decision to reform and most importantly to receive and accept forgiveness. The lack of the latter is a sure shot way to differentiate repentance from guilt.
Many lives and relationships have been wasted in nurturing guilt. God never wanted us to sit and wallow in self-pity and condemnation. God calls us to repentance. The movement of turning back and not getting stuck at the curve. He gifts us forgiveness and so must we to ourselves. May our moments of grace bring us to true repentance. May we experience true joy, forgiveness and freedom in our relationships and most importantly with God.
Copyright 2026 Gilda Rose Kalathil
Images: Canva








Leave a Reply